Statistical Accuracy and EU Contributions

The amount “we send the EU” should reflect the actual cash-flow to the EU. (Photo: Getty Images)

In short

Accuracy in public debate: The figures used by politicians, campaign groups and activists should be accurate.

Four important figures

There are four figures of interest regarding the UK’s contribution to the EU:

  • Post-abatement gross contribution: The amount the UK government actually sent to the EU institutions;
  • Net contribution (after public sector receipts): This amount reflects the direct effect of EU membership on UK government finances;
  • Net contribution (after public and private sector receipts): This amount represents the direct effect of EU membership on the UK economy.
This table quantifies the different figures, from HM Treasury statistics. (Image: BBC)

We do not send the ‘rebate’

Before any money is sent to the EU, a ‘rebate’ is applied. It is formally called the “Fontainebleau abatement”.

The abatement is applied before any money is transferred, meaning the post-abatement gross contribution is what we send. (Image: House of Commons Library)

Common Counterarguments

This section goes through some common counterarguments, observed on social media, by those maintain this erroneous claim.

‘We really send £365m a week’

No, this is a misuse of official statistics. We do not “send” the abatement.

It is plain that the abatement is not sent to the EU. (Image: ONS)

‘The rebate is controlled by the EU, so we should include it’

This is a false premise. Financial frameworks must be unanimously agreed:

‘£350m is the amount under the EU’s control’

The Vote Leave slogan was not about “control”: it included an empirical claim about how much “we send the EU”.

‘The rebate is effectively a credit’

Previously, the abatement was listed in the credit section of the ONS Pink Book.

Andrew Tyrie: “It is not in fact debited from the consolidated funds.” (Video: YouTube/OldQueen)
The gross contribution to the EU (“total debits”) has the series ID ‘GCSM’. (Photo: ONS)

‘Only Remoaners think the figure is wrong’

There is no debate on factual matters: only correction.

‘Of course the rebate is sent back to us. That is what a rebate means’

Congratulations on the ability to read a dictionary.

‘It doesn’t matter: it did not affect the result’

Accuracy in public debate is worthwhile on its own terms.

‘It will be true some day’

That implies it is false today.



Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store