A sticker reads:
“60–70% of hospital admissions and deaths are from people who have had 2 doses of the vaccines.”
That sticker provides a short link to “NHS SOURCE”. The document is not, in fact, from the National Health Service.
It is from the modelling sub-group advising the UK government. Despite the exact quote-marks, those words do not appear in the document. The sticker intends to paraphrase this part:
32. The resurgence in both hospitalisations and deaths is dominated by those that have received two doses of the vaccine, comprising around 60% and 70% of the wave respectively. This can be attributed to the high levels of uptake in the most at-risk age groups, such that immunisation failures account for more serious illness than unvaccinated individuals.
Given the nature of the protest, the implication is vaccines are thus ineffective. The figures do not refer to current admissions and deaths. Those numbers are about modelling the future.
Why is it plausible most hospitalisations are among vaccinated people?
We should avoid confusing the inverse. These two probabilities are different:
- The probability of hospital admission, given the person has two vaccine doses.
- The probability a person in hospital with the disease is vaccinated with two doses.
Suppose there were 1,000 people who — if infected — would get a serious illness. Assume a full vaccine course reduces the likelihood of hospital admission by 90%. Here, 950 people (95%) receive that vaccine. The remaining 50 go to hospital without it.
The vaccine is imperfect: among the vaccinated, 95 also go to hospital (as the assumed reduction is 90%). In this calculation, about two-thirds of those hospitalised after infection had vaccinations. That is different to the probability of hospitalisation after vaccination. That chance is 10% of its non-vaccinated probability.
We can write that paragraph in mathematical notation. Here, ℙ(V | H) means the probability they had a full vaccine (V), given they are in hospital (H):
This calculation depends on both vaccine coverage and effectiveness.
With wide vaccine coverage, a low proportion of failures can outnumber non-vaccinated people. As the modelling document states:
This is not the result of vaccines being ineffective, merely uptake being so high.
Probabilities can be confusing and counter-intuitive.